Fei-Fei Li and Lisa Su: A Few Thoughts on How Women Relate and Work Together

Fei-Fei Li and Lisa Su: A Few Thoughts on How Women Relate and Work Together

AMD has completed its acquisition of World Labs. Fei-Fei Li is joining the company as executive vice president and chief scientist, reporting directly to Lisa Su. Alongside what this means for artificial intelligence and the chip industry, one detail caught my attention: two women who have already achieved a great deal will now be working in the same company, with one reporting to the other. (Source: https://newsroom.amd.com/news/amd-completes-acquisition-world-labs/)

The question of whether women get along and work well together is easily oversimplified. Some believe women understand other women better; others are quick to say that a workplace full of women is bound to be full of drama. The first view expresses a hopeful expectation; the second carries an obvious prejudice. Relationships in everyday life are much more complicated. Friends who enjoy talking together may not be suited to running a business together. Two people who work exceptionally well together may never become close friends who tell each other everything.

One difference worth considering when we look at China alongside Europe and North America is how people tend to build trust. These are only some relatively common ways of relating, of course. There is enormous variation within China, and Europe and North America hardly constitute a single culture. Still, putting these differences into everyday situations can reveal something interesting.

In Chinese social life, people often prefer to get to know one another personally first. They share meals, talk about family, get a feel for each other’s temperament and gradually decide that the other person can be trusted. Working together then becomes easier. There is often a well-used passage between professional and personal relationships. Research on Chinese societies also describes this way of building trust through social contact, looking after one another and exchanging favours. (Source: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0361684315596161)

Closeness between women can bring a great deal of warmth to such relationships. Having someone who listens, helps when things are difficult and remembers what has been happening in your family is practical, meaningful support. The current enthusiasm for personal boundaries should not lead us to treat every expression of concern as interference, or every act of mutual care as an unwanted obligation.

Closeness can also bring expectations that nobody has quite put into words. Imagine two female colleagues who are good friends disagreeing about a proposal at a meeting. One simply thinks the proposal needs changing. The other may wonder why someone so close to her would contradict her in front of everyone. A difference over work becomes a doubt about the friendship. This happens between men too. But when we imagine women’s friendships as especially close, we are more likely to expect women to be understanding and supportive of one another, until even an open disagreement can seem disloyal.

Another principle of social interaction, often valued in Europe and North America, is that each person has a life, a position and responsibilities of their own. On that understanding, someone can be an excellent colleague or collaborator while retaining a considerable amount of personal space. Neither person needs to know every detail of the other’s family life, or agree on everything. People accustomed to more familiar, involved relationships may sometimes find this a little distant. Yet it offers a practical advantage: people can begin working together before they have become particularly close.

We should not assume that women elsewhere have no cliques, no tendency to compare themselves with others and no difficulties in their relationships. The need for recognition, sensitivity to being left out, and concern about resources and opportunities do not disappear when people speak a different language. Interestingly, a study comparing women managers in the technology sector in China and Finland found that, in both settings, ties between women served more of a social function, while ties associated with power and influence at work more often involved men. Having many female friends does not automatically mean women have an equally strong network for professional cooperation. (Source: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0147176713001041)

So there is still some distance between being close and working well together. Shared interests may be enough for a good conversation. Working together also means deciding who makes decisions, who takes responsibility and how the rewards are shared. However good the personal relationship, these matters cannot be left indefinitely to guesswork. Conversely, two people with different personalities can work very well together if they can discuss them clearly.

Which brings us back to Fei-Fei Li and Lisa Su.

The statement that Li will report directly to Su can easily be read as a ranking of the two women. Yet in a particular working arrangement, where one person is responsible for running the company and the other for scientific research, decision-making and reporting lines have to be established. Li’s academic standing does not diminish because she has a boss. Su’s responsibilities as the head of the company do not disappear because a person reporting to her is highly respected. Accepting another person’s authority in a particular area is different from accepting that you are worth less as a person.

If a culture readily treats someone’s position in an organisation as a measure of their standing as a person, this kind of cooperation may involve more psychological complications. Why should someone who is already successful take direction from someone else? Will bringing in another accomplished person affect the position one already holds? Men and women can both face these questions. When the two people are women, observers may be especially quick to imagine a rivalry before anything has happened, as though the more capable they are, the harder they must find it to get along.

In this respect, I lean towards the view that a culture which gives greater weight to personal independence and makes working roles clearer is more favourable to lasting cooperation between two women with minds of their own. A culture of closer personal ties has a different strength: once trust is established, people may be willing to do more for each other and look after one another more attentively. The former needs to guard against distance; the latter needs to leave room for disagreement and for saying no. These tendencies can help us understand cultural differences. They do not justify concluding that Chinese women are difficult to work with while women elsewhere are easy to work with.

Su and Li themselves also make that simple division rather awkward. Both are women of Chinese heritage, and both have spent many years in American education and technology. An outsider would struggle to separate familiar cultural habits from professional training or individual personality. We should at least avoid giving one culture all the credit when they cooperate, only to turn immediately to their gender for an explanation if they later disagree.

This working relationship is only just beginning, and we do not yet know how it will develop. It does suggest that relationships between women can take many forms. Some women become close friends; some look after one another; others can disagree and still carry a major undertaking forward together. Whether Li and Su work well together will ultimately depend on how they do their jobs. There is no need to decide in advance that they ought to become best friends.


Discover more from Geoffrey Chen

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.