
Shenzhen is making its final preparations for the APEC Economic Leaders’ Meeting on 18–19 November. From roadside greenery and street flowers to public signs and night-time lighting, many parts of the city have been freshened up. There is colour to enjoy during the day and lighting to admire at night; even the scent of flowers seems to have become part of the welcome. The attention to detail gives the impression of an entire city preparing for a major examination.
For Shenzhen, this is undoubtedly an important international occasion. Using it as an opportunity to improve the streetscape, public services and city management is certainly worthwhile. If work that might otherwise have taken years can be completed sooner, residents will ultimately benefit. At the same time, such concentrated preparations inevitably include elements that are temporary, one-off and staged for display. That is understandable for an event of this importance, but it has prompted another thought.
Having lived in China for several decades and in Australia for nearly twenty years, I have developed a particular interest in how cities present themselves.
Many years ago, before migrating to Australia, I visited Sydney as a tourist. The trip lasted only a few days, but it left a deep impression. After returning to Shenzhen, I was looking at the city’s high-rise buildings one evening when I suddenly realised how strikingly different the two cities looked at night.
In Sydney, I had seen office buildings with lights shining through their windows. The light came from individual rooms, some brighter and some dimmer, scattered unevenly across the buildings. The overall effect was a natural, slightly irregular glow. Back in Shenzhen, I often saw something quite different. Most windows in the towers were dark; the main sources of light were decorative fittings along the rooftops, edges and external walls. The outlines of the buildings stood out sharply, while the buildings themselves seemed to remain hidden in darkness.
Of course, the fact that some Sydney offices remained lit late at night was not necessarily something to celebrate. The lights might have been on for people working overtime, cleaners or security staff, or they might simply have reflected unnecessary energy use. What stayed with me was the visual impression created by the two kinds of light. One seemed to emerge naturally from within the building; the other looked like decoration added to its exterior.
Since then, I have watched many promotional videos showcasing Chinese cities at night. Large cities, smaller cities and even some county towns favour dense strips of light, vivid colours and sharply defined building outlines as a way of displaying prosperity. In recent years, large drone formations and more elaborate lighting displays have joined them. These spectacles can certainly be impressive, and they require technical skill and organisational ability. Yet I sometimes feel that what stands out most is a layer of carefully crafted packaging.
It reminds me of some mooncake gift boxes. The packaging can be astonishingly elaborate, attracting even more attention than the mooncakes themselves. A city’s nightscape can have a similar effect. People first see the image created by the lights, but that image may tell them little about the city in daylight: whether its streets are pleasant, its buildings attractive, or everyday life convenient for ordinary people.
I am not opposed to decorative lighting. Light is part of urban art, and a carefully designed performance can have aesthetic value in its own right. Vivid Sydney, for example, brings together architectural projections, music, interactive installations and artistic creation, giving people a reason to visit the city to experience the works themselves.
Still, it would be inaccurate to describe Shenzhen’s light shows as nothing more than a few laser beams. Years ago, the city already had themed performances unfolding in chapters across its buildings, and it has invited international creative teams, including Australian artists, to contribute. Sydney’s festival also uses lasers and drones. The question, then, is not which city has more sophisticated lighting equipment or more advanced technology.
What concerns me more is why a city feels such urgency to prove itself through powerful visual effects, and how closely those effects relate to its everyday appearance.
A light show can be art, and an international conference can be welcomed with elaborate decorations. Both are perfectly normal. But when people become accustomed to judging a city’s modernity by ever greater brightness, colour and scale, it becomes easy to mistake the intensity of its display for the maturity of the city itself.
A mature city can still hold grand festivals and use decorations. It should be able to sustain cleanliness, order, convenience and aesthetic quality in everyday life. Even when no important visitors are expected, roads should be maintained, public signs should remain clear, greenery should be cared for, and buildings and streets should still feel pleasant. When a festival arrives, the city can add some wonderful events; once it is over, it should remain a city worth living in.
As Shenzhen prepares to welcome APEC, perhaps the changes most worth looking forward to are those that will remain after the meeting. Flowers will fade, decorative lights will be switched off and welcome banners will come down. But improved public spaces, more convenient services and more attentive management, if maintained, will gradually become part of the city’s own character.
To me, the most convincing sign of maturity is that it does not need to wait for a grand occasion to become visible.
Maturity is the everyday norm.
Discover more from Geoffrey Chen
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.