At the close of Liber Primus, Jung has learned a difficult lesson: an inner voice must neither be evaded nor obeyed without question. In Liber Secundus, this relation becomes concrete in figures, scenes and conflicts. The Red One is the first major figure to arrive with forceful reality. He is rough, worldly and charged with desire and action. He stands in direct contrast to the soul, the spirit of the depths and the inward calling that shaped the earlier book.
1. Place in The Red Book: Entering Liber Secundus
“The Red One” opens Liber Secundus. This position matters. Liber Primus has mainly performed a negative task: Jung separates from the rule of the spirit of the age, recognises the loss of soul, relinquishes the old heroic ideal, and begins to hear what comes from the depths. Yet those steps could still leave the misleading impression that the inner path is simply a higher, purer or more spiritual life.
The Red One immediately breaks that illusion. He does not represent refined spirituality. He brings body, desire, pleasure, masculine rivalry, coarse speech and the demands of ordinary life back before Jung. If Jung is genuinely to move toward wholeness, he cannot accept only what he is willing to call noble. He must also meet vital forces that make him uneasy or ashamed.
2. Chapter Summary: A Companion of a Completely Different Kind
In this chapter Jung meets the Red One and travels and speaks with him. The figure first appears rough and alien. His orientation differs sharply from Jung’s habitual spiritual stance. He is not a teacher dispensing abstract truths, nor does he ask Jung to transcend the world. Instead, he repeatedly draws Jung back toward the world and exposes Jung’s rejection of desire, ordinary life and instinctual force.
The conflict is not simply that of a civilised person meeting a barbarian. The Red One is disturbing not because he represents only what is low or evil, but because he carries an entire region of life that Jung’s consciousness has held down. Jung knows the languages of spirit, thought, responsibility and inward meaning. The Red One reminds him that when life is reduced to spiritual striving alone, life itself returns in an unfamiliar, rough and potentially destructive form.
3. Key Image: Why Red?
Red should not be reduced here to a fixed code. It first produces a sensory impression: heat, blood, passion, danger, impulse, anger and vitality. With the Red One, The Red Book moves from the inward calling of Liber Primus into a world with greater bodily weight. He is not a concept but a presence that prevents Jung from maintaining his earlier image of a clean and elevated self.
Later Jungian psychology can relate such a figure to shadow, repressed instinct and the personified unconscious. Those concepts can help us approach the chapter, but they cannot replace it. If we simply say that the Red One “is the shadow”, the figure loses complexity. Shadow contains not only what is bad, but also capacities the ego has failed to live because they do not fit identity, moral image or social expectation.
4. The Red One Is Not a Licence for Indulgence
This chapter can easily be misread as a celebration of desire and instinct. Jung is not moving directly from repression to indulgence. He faces a stricter task: acknowledge desire as part of life without raising it into the only truth. The Red One does not exist to replace Jung’s consciousness; he exists to break its one-sidedness.
This is where Jung differs from the usual slogan of simply being oneself. Authenticity is not the immediate expression of every impulse. Once an impulse is acknowledged, it can be understood, limited and placed within a larger structure of life. Total denial lets it operate in the background; total submission abandons choice. Integration is not compromise. It is an order capable of holding desire, judgement, relationship and responsibility together.
5. The Red One and Jung’s Self-Image
The Red One first strikes at Jung’s self-image. Jung is a doctor, a thinker, a well-educated European bourgeois man, and someone intensely concerned with spiritual meaning. The Red One is another masculine possibility outside that image: direct, combative, pleasure-seeking, worldly and unconcerned with appearing elevated. Their tension makes Jung reconsider whether his own spirituality has become a form of avoidance.
The criticism extends beyond Jung. Anyone can turn a cherished virtue into a defence. Rationality can avoid feeling; morality can avoid desire; diligence can avoid emptiness; spirituality can avoid the body, ordinary reality and relationship. The Red One is necessary because he forces the ego to see that what it rejects may not be merely inferior. It may be a part of life it has not yet learned to carry.
6. Relation to the Whole of The Red Book
“The Red One” establishes the basic form of Liber Secundus. Inner problems are no longer abstract propositions but become concrete figures demanding relation. A castle, an anchorite, a magician, the dead and more complex religious scenes will follow. None of these figures can be treated as a simple symbol. Each carries a psychic force Jung must meet but cannot govern from the ego alone.
The transition from “Instruction” to this chapter is clear. Entry 11 asks how consciousness should meet an inner voice; entry 12 shows that a genuine inner voice may not sound noble or fit our aesthetic image of depth. The inner world does not bring comfort alone. It also exposes the life we have excluded.
7. Chapter Conclusion
The Red One is neither another self Jung ought to become nor an enemy he ought to eliminate. He brings Jung before desire, instinct and ordinary life excluded by a spiritualised ego. The real work is not to choose either spirit or instinct, but to bring both into a relation in which they no longer destroy one another. That relation cannot be completed in one chapter, but Liber Secundus begins here.
Q&A
1. Who is the Red One?
He is first an inner figure in The Red Book, carrying an unfamiliar and vital psychic force Jung must meet; he cannot be reduced to one concept.
2. Is the Red One the shadow?
He can be related to shadow, but should not be equated with it. Shadow is a later concept; the figure’s concrete relation and tension matter more.
3. Does the chapter encourage indulgence?
No. It requires acknowledgement of desire and instinct, not their elevation into the sole rule.
4. Why does the Red One unsettle Jung?
Because he shows that spiritual striving can also conceal body, desire and ordinary life.
5. What is the chapter’s central question?
How can excluded vital force enter consciousness without ruling it?
6. Why does it open Liber Secundus?
Because from here inner conflict unfolds continuously through concrete figures and relationships.
Discover more from Geoffrey Chen
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.