After leaving the remains of earlier temples, Jung travels east alone. He has refused the rule of exhausted moral ideals, only to meet a presence far larger than those ideals in Chapter VIII of Liber Secundus, “First Day”—Izdubar. The name arose from an early scholarly misreading of the cuneiform name now rendered Gilgamesh. Jung knew the corrected form but retained Izdubar, indicating a figure related to the epic hero without simply reproducing him.
Izdubar has bull horns, armour and a double axe. His body is enormous, yet his face is pale and his knees tremble. He travels westward from the land of light in search of the place where the sun descends and is renewed; Jung travels from western darkness towards the east. They meet at the border of morning and evening—one possessing mythical force without modern knowledge, the other possessing modern knowledge while physically small and spiritually impoverished.
Meeting at the Boundary
Izdubar travels from light towards night, while Jung seeks the rising sun from darkness. Each lacks what the other carries. The god needs night, death and renewal; modern man needs myth, force and a larger scale of life.
This is not the simple claim that eastern spirituality is superior to western science. Izdubar is fearful and ignorant of the physical structure of the world; Jung is weak but bears knowledge capable of transforming a god. Their conflict occurs within mutual need.
Izdubar: Fear Within Monumental Strength
The horns, armour and axe make Izdubar a solar hero, warrior and god. His scale overwhelms Jung. Yet he is not self-sufficient. He seeks the destination of the sun and fears the edge of the world and death.
Jung is first captivated by his power, then notices trembling hands and knees. The god’s fear is concealed within grandeur. His later paralysis does not arrive without preparation; modern knowledge touches an existing vulnerability.
Why Scientific Facts Act Like Poison
Jung tells Izdubar that the earth is spherical, that the sun does not enter a mysterious western land, and that immense space lies beyond the visible sky. These are ordinary facts to a modern person but they collapse Izdubar’s cosmos.
Facts themselves are not malicious. The problem is that the god’s power depends upon a particular world-picture. When astronomy, geography and sacred meaning remain one structure, the solar journey is both event and divine story. Modern knowledge separates measurable structure from mythical meaning and removes the old god’s dwelling place.
Knowledge and Truth Are Not the Same Level
Jung describes western truth as knowledge of outer things, while Izdubar’s priests receive truth through inward things. This does not mean that science is false and inward feeling true. Science is reliable within its domain and the physical earth cannot be denied for the sake of mythology.
The criticism concerns exclusivity. When external knowledge declares that only measurable contents are real, myth, meaning, emotion and fantasy become invalid. Knowledge expands while the lived world contracts.
The Two Faces of Logos
Reason helped humanity resist superstition, develop science and increase control over external conditions. Jung does not erase those achievements. Yet Logos made absolute excludes everything that cannot prove itself in rational form.
Izdubar loses movement before this reason. Jung suspects that the West has not only diminished its gods but also stunted human beings. Our tools and information grow, while the psychological capacities for belief, awe and meaning weaken.
Who Has Wounded Whom?
On the surface Jung poisons Izdubar with science. At a deeper level both become trapped. The god cannot walk and Jung cannot abandon him. If Izdubar dies, Jung’s own life will divide; if Jung denies science, he cannot honestly return to antiquity.
There is no simple retreat. Modern people cannot recover myth by pretending not to know, and cannot preserve it by dismissing it as failed science. Jung needs a form in which scientific fact and psychological reality cease cancelling one another.
The Outer Opposition Mirrors an Inner One
Jung recognises that the conflict of East and West also divides him. He is a doctor and scientist who cannot deny the force of dreams, religious images and fantasy. Izdubar is not merely a cultural object but a massive vitality diminished by modern consciousness.
Argument over which side is correct cannot heal the division. Science is true on the external level; Izdubar is real on the psychological level. The task is to construct a form capable of sustaining both kinds of reality.
The Sick God: Why Divinity Requires Human Care
Traditional religion usually presents weak humanity as dependent upon God. The chapter reverses the relation. The god lies paralysed and the human being must remain with him. Worship alone cannot cure him, while ridicule would destroy a source of life.
“God needs man” is not offered here as metaphysical proof. It is a psychological experience. Symbols, values and ultimate concerns weaken if no human life bears them. Divinity does not persist as an automatic public object; it requires attention, imagination, responsibility and renewed form.
Original Experience, Later Theory, Contemporary Interpretation
The original experience is Jung’s meeting with Izdubar, the scientific disclosure that brings the god down, and Jung’s refusal to abandon him. Later theory may call Izdubar a god-image, archetypal energy or a force within the development of the Self, but those concepts should not replace the scene.
Contemporary interpretation may examine disenchantment, scientism, separation of fact and meaning, and crisis after the collapse of a cognitive world. Science must remain distinct from scientism: the first is a disciplined method of knowledge; the second turns that method into the sole judge of every layer of reality.
Conclusion: Modernity Cannot Go Back
“First Day” offers no treatment. Jung must accept responsibility for what his knowledge has done. He cannot withdraw the spherical earth, yet he cannot allow Izdubar to die. The unresolved contradiction passes directly into “Second Day”.
There Jung will discover that an external giant occupying physical space cannot be carried, but a god recognised as fantasy can become light, small and transportable. Calling Izdubar a fantasy will not make him less real. It will change the mode in which he can live.
Questions and Answers
1. Who is Izdubar?
He is related to Gilgamesh, but the older misread name becomes a distinct figure in Jung’s imagination.
2. Why does Jung retain the old name?
It marks the figure as more than a straightforward retelling of the historical epic.
3. Where do Jung and Izdubar meet?
At a boundary of East and West, light and darkness, ascent and descent.
4. Why does Izdubar travel west?
He seeks the place where the sun descends, dies and receives renewed life.
5. Why does the god tremble?
His monumental power conceals fear of death and the world’s limits.
6. What knowledge paralyses him?
Modern astronomy and geography destroy the mythical structure of his cosmos.
7. Is Jung opposed to science?
No. He opposes making scientific method the only measure of reality and meaning.
8. How do outer knowledge and inner truth differ?
One studies observable conditions; the other concerns meaning, symbol and psychic experience.
9. Why can fact act like poison?
Within a world wholly dependent upon an older cosmology, factual correction can collapse the entire structure of meaning.
10. Can Jung pretend not to know science?
No. Modern consciousness cannot honestly return to discarded physical beliefs.
11. Why would Izdubar’s death wound Jung?
The god carries a scale of vitality, belief and myth missing from Jung’s modern life.
12. What does the outer opposition mirror?
It mirrors Jung’s own division between scientific identity and inward symbolic experience.
13. Why does a god need human care?
Symbols and values require human attention and embodiment if they are to receive new form.
14. Is Izdubar simply the Self?
Later theory may connect them, but the chapter first presents a particular god who fears and suffers.
15. Why is the chapter called “First Day”?
It is the first day of Jung’s encounter with the stricken Izdubar; the crisis continues in the next chapter.
16. What is the central problem?
Modern people can neither deny science nor allow myth and meaning to die; they need a form capable of bearing both.
Discover more from Geoffrey Chen
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.