Why Does the Middle Pedal Sustain Only Selected Notes?

The middle pedal of a grand piano is usually the sostenuto pedal. Its main difference from the right pedal is not how long sound is prolonged, but which notes are prolonged. Hold a bass note or chord first, then depress the middle pedal: the mechanism catches only the dampers already raised. Those selected notes continue after the fingers leave, while notes played later stop normally when their keys are released. The right pedal, by contrast, raises all dampers and brings later notes into the same resonance.

This selectivity lets the piano maintain two different layers of musical time. A bass can remain as a harmonic ground while the upper line articulates clearly, breathes or moves quickly. The right pedal may accumulate each new note and blur the texture; holding the bass with the fingers may make the later writing impossible. The sostenuto pedal is therefore not merely a substitute for an extra hand. It allows one sound to continue without granting every subsequent sound the same extension.

Order matters. The notes must be held before the pedal catches their dampers. If the foot goes down first, dampers that are still resting will not be selected. Many upright pianos also use the middle pedal as a practice mute rather than a true sostenuto. The player should first hear which layer needs to remain, then decide whether selective sustain is required. The pedal's musical purpose is not simply to add resonance, but to set its boundary.

https://usa.yamaha.com/products/contents/musical_instrument_guide/piano/selection/index.html
https://hub.yamaha.com/pianos/p-acoustic/how-does-a-piano-work/