A Teachers’ Strike and the Dilemmas of Keeping Society Running

A Teachers’ Strike and the Dilemmas of Keeping Society Running

The industrial dispute between Canberra’s public school teachers and the government continues. The teachers’ union is dissatisfied with the government’s latest offer on pay and working conditions. It argues that the proposed increases are insufficient to keep pace with the rising cost of living, and that longstanding problems such as staff shortages and excessive workloads have not been adequately resolved.

From the teachers’ perspective, these demands are entirely understandable. As prices rise, housing, food, transport and other everyday expenses increase. If wages fail to keep pace with living costs, teachers lose purchasing power. At the same time, they are taking on more teaching and administrative work. Negotiating through a union and, where necessary, taking lawful strike action to seek better pay and conditions are normal ways of expressing and pursuing interests in a modern society.

The government, however, faces difficulties of its own. Public finances are finite. Beyond education, it must maintain substantial spending on health care, transport, infrastructure, social security and other services. Any increase in teachers’ pay must be considered alongside government revenue, wages in other sectors and the capacity to sustain that spending in the future.

Parents have a different perspective again. They may support teachers’ efforts to secure fair conditions and want schools to have enough staff and a good teaching environment. But when a strike closes schools, children’s learning and families’ everyday arrangements are disrupted.

A significant pattern emerges here. Teachers, the government and parents all make demands shaped by their circumstances. Each has reasonable grounds for doing so, yet their demands do not fully align and may even conflict.

This situation is certainly not confined to education.

Drivers in the transport industry may also seek higher wages as living costs rise. If negotiations fail, they too may take lawful strike action. Drivers need to support themselves, transport companies need to stay in business, and other industries depend on transport to maintain production and sales.

The difficulty is that transport underpins the entire economic system. Moving raw materials to factories, transferring semi-finished goods between businesses and bringing finished products to market all require transport services.

When transport costs rise, production and operating costs in other industries may rise with them. Businesses may increase their prices to preserve profits. As more goods and services become more expensive, employees in other sectors find that their existing wages no longer support their previous standard of living, and they too begin seeking pay increases.

Higher wages may then increase business costs and prompt another round of price adjustments. Through the connections between industries, an action taken by one sector to improve its position can affect society as a whole and eventually feed back into that sector itself.

This is the mechanism economists discuss when examining how wages and prices can push one another upwards.

Of course, a wage increase does not invariably lead to higher prices. Businesses can absorb costs through productivity gains, lower profit margins or better management. Competition and consumers’ purchasing power also constrain price increases. This cycle therefore need not accelerate indefinitely, and inflation certainly cannot all be attributed to workers seeking higher wages.

Even with these buffers, a basic fact remains. Economic relationships between industries are highly interdependent, and an adjustment within one sector often changes the conditions under which others operate.

What deserves further thought is that no participant in this process necessarily deserves blame.

Drivers want higher wages, teachers want better conditions, businesses want to preserve profits, consumers want to contain living costs, and governments want fiscal stability. Each may make reasonable choices in their own circumstances. Yet the interaction of those choices can produce an outcome that none of them wants.

Why can a society made up of countless reasonable demands and rational choices repeatedly produce unreasonable outcomes as a whole?

This is a broader problem of how society functions that becomes visible through a specific event such as a teachers’ strike.

Australia’s current economic circumstances provide a practical background for understanding these relationships.

According to the Australian Bureau of Statistics, the national Consumer Price Index rose by 4.3 per cent over the year to September 2026, with housing, transport and other living costs continuing to face substantial upward pressure. On 3 November, the Reserve Bank of Australia raised its cash rate target again, taking it to 4.85 per cent.

The central bank raises interest rates to restrain excessive demand and inflationary pressure, gradually bringing price increases back to a more stable pace. Yet higher interest rates themselves create new economic pressures.

Households with mortgages face higher interest payments, and businesses face higher financing costs. Some households have to cut consumption, while some businesses may postpone investment. Economic growth and employment can both be affected.

Another relationship of mutual constraint takes shape. The central bank raises rates to contain inflation, but higher rates add to the financial burden on some households and businesses. Those burdens may, in turn, affect wage negotiations, consumption and business operations.

This does not mean that rate increases are unnecessary, or that the central bank must be trapped in an insoluble cycle. Monetary policy can restrain demand and inflation expectations. Its effects take time, however, and it requires trade-offs between stabilising prices, maintaining employment and limiting economic damage.

There is therefore no variable in the economic system that can be adjusted independently without affecting any other part.

Wages, prices, interest rates, employment, consumption, investment and public finances remain interconnected. A change in one condition can bring changes in others. Relieving a problem in one industry may create new pressure in another.

How, then, should the relationships between all these industries be coordinated?

Can humanity establish a model for economic activity that gives every industry reasonable room to develop and enables everyone to keep improving their lives, without society repeatedly falling into inflation, recession, unemployment and other conflicts as a result of these pursuits of particular interests?

This is a more fundamental question than wage negotiations or economic policy alone.

Throughout history, people have developed many economic theories and institutions for governing society. Market economies coordinate resource allocation through prices, competition and exchange. Governments intervene through fiscal policy, public services and social security, while central banks influence economic activity through monetary policy. Unions, industry bodies and labour laws also provide an institutional basis for negotiating between different groups.

These mechanisms have played important roles at different historical stages. Yet no economic model can guarantee that society as a whole will remain in an optimal state forever.

At some times, economic growth is strong, employment is plentiful, prices are relatively stable and living standards keep rising. But these conditions often change with technology, population, industrial structures, the international environment and social needs. Economic arrangements that once worked may gradually reveal new tensions.

Society seems to be in a continual process of adjustment. People begin looking for solutions once a problem reaches a certain point. After an institution has been established, new circumstances bring new problems.

To a considerable extent, human civilisation has developed through this process of encountering difficulties, learning from experience, establishing institutions and then facing further problems.

This brings to mind riding a bicycle.

A bicycle’s ability to move forward does not mean that it remains in some absolutely static state of balance. The road, speed and centre of gravity keep changing, and the rider maintains stability by continually adjusting direction and weight.

A bicycle’s stability is closely connected to its motion. But this does not mean that continual acceleration will necessarily keep it balanced. If its speed exceeds the rider’s ability to control it, or road conditions change suddenly, it can still lose stability.

Human society has a similar character in some respects. It has no ideal position in which it can remain fixed forever. It sustains its overall functioning through the changing relationships between its parts.

There is, however, an important difference in this analogy. A bicycle has a rider who can change direction according to their judgement. Human society has no single agent capable of fully controlling how the whole operates.

Society consists of countless individuals, businesses, industries and organisations. Each participant has limited information and different goals. Governments and central banks have the capacity to regulate economic activity at a broad level, but they cannot anticipate every economic change, let alone precisely control everyone’s behaviour.

The stability of society as a whole must emerge through the continuing interactions of these different agents.

A deeper question concerns why the economic system needs to keep developing at all.

We usually understand economic development as a way to meet humanity’s growing material and non-material needs. As living standards rise, people naturally want better housing, more comprehensive health care, higher-quality education and a richer cultural life.

Yet there is a relationship here that deserves further study.

As productive capacity grows and existing needs are met, new technologies and living conditions often create further needs.

In the past, ordinary households did not need the internet, smartphones or various digital services, because these things did not yet exist. Once technology made these ways of living possible, they gradually became important parts of everyday life.

Today, people may want better artificial intelligence services, more advanced medical technologies and more efficient transport. Future technological developments may bring needs that are not yet fully recognised.

Human needs are therefore not a predetermined, fixed total waiting to be satisfied once and for all through production.

We need to distinguish potential human needs from effective demand in the economic sense. At any particular time, society can certainly experience overproduction and insufficient purchasing power. We therefore cannot claim that aggregate market demand must always exceed aggregate supply.

Over the long development of human civilisation, however, the relationship between needs and the capacity to satisfy them can continue to change as society develops.

The process of satisfying needs can itself create the conditions for new needs to arise.

This means that success at one stage of economic development does not automatically bring its goals to a state of permanent completion.

Society creates more wealth, increases productive capacity and improves living standards. At the same time, people’s expectations of life may rise further. Conditions that once seemed satisfactory may later seem inadequate.

This is a process that keeps unfolding.

If part of the impetus behind human civilisation comes from the difference between needs and the existing capacity to satisfy them, that difference may continually regenerate itself.

Difference alone, however, is insufficient to explain how civilisation can keep developing. A society must sustain its capacity to produce wealth as well as create new wealth.

An engine offers another way of understanding this.

An engine needs fuel and oxygen to run, along with functioning lubrication, cooling and control systems. Some of its mechanical output drives an external load, while some may support its own operation through auxiliary systems.

The social and economic system requires a similar process of self-maintenance.

Society cannot devote all the wealth it produces to present consumption. It must also invest resources in education, infrastructure, technological research, equipment renewal, public administration and other activities that sustain future productive capacity.

Education prepares the next generation of workers. Infrastructure supports economic activity. Scientific research and technological renewal improve the conditions of production. Laws and social institutions provide the order needed for cooperation, exchange and the coordination of interests.

If the conditions that sustain the system’s own operation are damaged, society’s future capacity to develop may gradually decline even while current economic activity remains prosperous.

Economic development therefore concerns more than the relationship between supply and demand. It also concerns how society sustains and improves the conditions for its continued functioning while meeting present needs.

Two interconnected processes become visible here.

In one, production and technological progress continually expand humanity’s capacity to meet needs, while that expanded capacity may give rise to further needs.

In the other, society must continually invest resources in maintaining and renewing the structures through which it functions, or risk losing its ability to develop further.

Together, these processes give human civilisation a character of continually propelling itself forward while changing the conditions of its own operation.

But the impetus for development does not automatically determine its direction.

Industries may compete because of their respective interests. Resources may become excessively concentrated in certain areas, and the environment and social institutions may face pressures beyond their capacities. Even continual growth in productive capacity does not necessarily ensure a reasonable distribution of wealth, still less a simultaneous reduction in the pressures everyone faces in life.

This returns us to the tension first seen in the teachers’ strike.

The different parts of a society all seek to improve their own circumstances. Yet the overall outcome of those efforts may not serve the shared interests of all participants.

The impetus that social development requires may also become a source of conflict and imbalance.

If this tension is a recurring structural problem in how society functions, can humanity fundamentally improve that way of functioning?

Can we design more mature mechanisms of economic and social coordination, so that industries no longer pursue their interests primarily by exerting pressure on one another, wage growth rests more firmly on productivity and increases in real wealth, and improvements in living standards are less readily translated into fresh inflationary pressure?

More broadly, can society establish a structure that works over the long term, keeping economic growth, resource distribution, public services and personal life reasonably coordinated, while avoiding as far as possible repeated adjustments through crises, unemployment, strikes and economic losses?

Neither free market competition nor an increase in government management and intervention provides a simple answer.

Markets can coordinate dispersed economic activity through price signals, but price changes can themselves create new distributional pressures. Governments can regulate the economy at a broad level, but face limits in information, finances, institutions and the effectiveness of policy.

Different economic theories can explain some of these mechanisms. Relying on any one of them alone, however, is unlikely to resolve all the tensions in society’s functioning over the long term.

What needs to be studied here is the relationship between difference, constraint and coordination within society itself.

Difference can motivate action. A gap between needs and actual conditions prompts people to try to improve their circumstances. Differences in interests between industries create the need for competition, cooperation and negotiation.

But differences can also grow to the point of disrupting the functioning of the whole. Without the necessary coordination and constraints, the pursuit of interests by individual parts may produce mutually reinforcing negative outcomes.

A society that continues to function must therefore allow differences to exist while preventing their interactions from repeatedly damaging its basic structure.

This involves more than finding a single most reasonable level of wages, prices or interest rates.

Even if a relatively ideal set of economic parameters could be calculated for a particular period, there would be no guarantee that they would remain suitable. Technological progress changes production conditions, demographic shifts change social needs, new industries change employment and income distribution, and individual and collective judgements about quality of life continue to evolve.

If the conditions of an optimal state keep changing, a fixed optimal state is unlikely to last forever.

Yet it would be equally hasty to conclude that humanity can only respond passively to crises forever.

The absence of permanently optimal economic parameters does not imply the absence of enduring principles of social coordination.

For example, we can investigate how a society might promptly detect the effects of changes in particular interests on the whole, establish more effective negotiation mechanisms before conflicts escalate, distribute the wealth created by productivity gains more reasonably, and reduce the social costs of each economic adjustment.

Such mechanisms may not eliminate every conflict, but they could gradually reduce society’s reliance on severe imbalances and remedies applied after the event.

A more difficult question nevertheless remains.

How should we judge whether a society as a whole functions more reasonably than it did before?

Does faster economic growth mean that society is functioning better? Does lower inflation mean that people are happier? Are higher wages enough to demonstrate a more reasonable distribution of resources?

These indicators matter, but each reflects only part of how society functions.

An economic system may sustain growth over a long period while leaving some groups to bear excessive costs. It may also achieve short-term stability by tightly restricting certain economic activities, at the expense of technological progress and opportunities for personal development.

We may therefore need to consider more than whether an economic system can remain stable. We must also ask what that stability costs, whether it allows individuals and society to continue developing, and whether the system can adjust when new conditions emerge.

This takes the question beyond ordinary economic management to the philosophical foundations of how society functions.

Humanity has long sought better social institutions, more effective economic policies and more reasonable ways of distributing resources. But do we really understand how a society composed of countless autonomous agents can form an overall order? Why does that order repeatedly become unbalanced? What conditions allow it to endure and keep improving?

We may not yet have answered these questions adequately.

Modern economics and research into complex systems offer many theories explaining how local behaviour produces aggregate outcomes, how feedback mechanisms generate stability or imbalance, and how institutions influence social cooperation. Yet these insights have not produced a complete model that can ensure the harmonious development of human civilisation over the long term.

Nor should the complexity of an economic system simply be equated with chaos in the mathematical sense. The difficulty of making precise economic predictions may arise from large numbers of interacting agents, insufficient information, institutional change and external shocks. It does not necessarily mean that the economy conforms to a strict model of chaos.

The question worth pursuing is whether humanity can develop a deeper theory of how society functions while acknowledging this complexity.

Such a theory need not calculate in advance how much income each industry should receive, or require every member of society to accept identical goals. It should, however, explain what differences of interest can promote sustained development, what constraints can prevent competition among individual parts from damaging the whole, and how society can improve both its capacity to develop and its capacity to coordinate through continual adjustment.

Whether such a theory is possible remains an open question.

Returning to the industrial dispute involving Canberra’s teachers, the teachers want fairer remuneration, the government needs to control public spending, and parents want their children to attend school as usual. The parties seek solutions through the law, unions, negotiation and public discussion.

This is a practical mechanism of social coordination. It also shows, however, that some adjustments still depend on conflicts of interest being explicitly expressed.

If this mechanism resolves the problem, that is certainly a form of social progress. Over the longer term, though, we can still ask whether a more mature form of coordination is possible, one that does not always wait until tensions have accumulated and conflict has emerged before rearranging relationships between the parts.

Human civilisation has created highly complex systems of production and forms of social organisation. Our technologies are increasingly advanced, and we can produce far more wealth than in the past. Economic fluctuations, conflicts of interest and the pressures of daily life have nevertheless persisted.

This does not necessarily mean that human development has taken a fundamentally wrong direction. It does at least suggest that growth in productive capacity and improvements in society’s overall capacity for coordination do not proceed in complete synchrony.

Could human civilisation enter a more mature stage in which productive capacity, social needs and mechanisms of coordination form more stable and effective relationships?

If such a state cannot be permanently fixed, can we find a generally applicable operating principle that allows society to remain coordinated through continual change, reduce unnecessary conflict and loss, and keep improving human life?

Or do the continual expansion of needs, the ongoing differentiation of interests and the ways in which each part changes the operating conditions of others mean that human civilisation can never fundamentally escape this repeated process of adjustment?

This is the philosophical question that ultimately emerges from practical phenomena such as teachers’ strikes, competition between industries, inflation and interest rate adjustments.

I do not think we currently have sufficient grounds to give it a definite answer.

But I think the question itself deserves serious study. It concerns more than resolving a particular strike, a round of inflation or an economic crisis. It asks whether humanity can discover a more general principle of coordination within the basic structure of social life.

If such a principle exists, we may be able to establish a more mature way for civilisation to function while acknowledging social differences and preserving individual autonomy and the impetus for development.

If such a principle is fundamentally impossible, we likewise need to explain why, and identify the irreducible conditions that constrain the continuing development of human society.

Whatever the eventual answer, this question should not remain solely at the level of economic policy. It concerns why human civilisation must keep developing, why development repeatedly generates new tensions, and whether a society that is always changing can achieve the lasting harmony we hope for.


Discover more from Geoffrey Chen

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.